Last week, during a book launch speech, the secretary of state for education, Michael Gove referred to under achievement in some North East schools, particularly those in East Durham. This comment in particular has provoked an angry response from local MPs Phil Wilson and Grahame Morris:
“When you go into those schools, you can smell the sense of defeatism.”
If Gove’s statement is a boast about his olfactory perception, it takes little effort to unpick.
The Northern Echo reports Gove’s belief that, in East Durham there is a “problem of ambition in certain traditional communities”. For traditional, read working class, and you can see how this statement taps into an idea that the causes of educational underachievement amongst working class children lies with the culture within working class communities, rather than with structural inequalities where working class communities are disadvantaged. However, on this occasion Gove is careful not to directly accuse East Durham parents of a poverty of ambition. His specific target, in this current attack is not the parents, but the organisation of schooling in Durham. Thus, his target reveals his motivation. He is taking an aim at the Labour run Durham County Council and the schools themselves:
“It is the case that there’s no choice, the local council has been one party for many years”
In this way Gove is drawing on the rhetoric of choice promoted in the academies and free school initiatives. In other words he stands in opposition to the collective approach of local authority schooling, the simplistic rationale being that collectivity limits choice, and therefore restricts individuality. It is an attack designed to weaken the teaching profession, by laying the blame for apparent failures in education at their hands, in an effort to justify the case for the privatisation of schools.
- On what evidence the Education Secretary based his views about East Durham schools?
- How many schools he has visited in the area?
- Whether has been told of “defeatism” by any heads, teachers or parents in East Durham?